| Player | Goals | First | Latest |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wayne Rooney | 53 | 06 Sep 2003 | 27 Jun 2016 |
| Bobby Charlton | 49 | 19 Apr 1958 | 20 May 1970 |
| Gary Lineker | 48 | 26 Mar 1985 | 29 Apr 1992 |
| Jimmy Greaves | 44 | 17 May 1959 | 24 May 1967 |
| Michael Owen | 40 | 27 May 1998 | 12 Sep 2007 |
| Alan Shearer | 30 | 19 Feb 1992 | 20 Jun 2000 |
| Tom Finney | 30 | 28 Sep 1946 | 04 Oct 1958 |
| Nat Lofthouse | 30 | 22 Nov 1950 | 22 Oct 1958 |
| Vivian Woodward | 29 | 14 Feb 1903 | 13 Mar 1911 |
| Frank Lampard | 29 | 20 Aug 2003 | 29 May 2013 |