article stringclasses 5
values | scenario stringclasses 3
values | use_case int64 1 10 | compliance_score int64 1 5 ⌀ | compliance_explanation stringclasses 55
values | plausibility_score int64 1 5 ⌀ | plausibility_explanation stringclasses 56
values | annotator stringclasses 1
value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Art 9 | Scenario A | 1 | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 9. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 9, such as requirements related to adequately modifying the system in regard to risk, such as by modifying the system in a reasonable time. However, the just... | null | 3 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario A | 2 | null | 1 | null | human | |
Art 9 | Scenario A | 3 | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9. However, the excerpt generally could provide more information on requirements like continuous risk-monitoring and . Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | 1 | I believe there is a very low probability the AI system complies with Article 9. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 9, such as adequately managing risks continuously or adequately mitigating known biases with the system. Additionally, the justifications and mitigation... | human |
Art 9 | Scenario A | 4 | null | 5 | null | 5 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario A | 5 | null | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | human | |
Art 9 | Scenario A | 6 | 1 | I believe there is a very low probability the AI system complies with Article 9. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 9, such as comprehensively managing risks rathe than doing so narrowly or mitigating known or potential risks. Additionally, the justifications and miti... | null | 3 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario A | 7 | null | 1 | null | human | |
Art 9 | Scenario A | 8 | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9. However, the excerpt generally could provide more information on the post-market risks of the system, for which there is primarily only 1 sentence. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | 1 | I believe there is a very low probability the AI system complies with Article 9. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 9, such as adequately mitigating issues with bias and non-representative data or adequately handling post-market monitoring. Additionally, the justifica... | human |
Art 9 | Scenario A | 9 | null | 4 | null | 1 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario A | 10 | null | 3 | I believe there is a moderate probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses Article 9. However, the excerpt generally could provide more information on mitigating risks, for which there are only a few sentences for such despite seemingly being a significant requirement for Articl... | human | |
Art 9 | Scenario B | 1 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the AI system complies with Article 9. This is because the system generally complies with all requirements of Article 9. Additionally, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may not comply with Article 9 are generally reasonable to me, such as mitigating risks... | null | 4 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario B | 2 | null | 1 | null | human | |
Art 9 | Scenario B | 3 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the AI system complies with Article 9. This is because the system generally complies with all requirements of Article 9. However, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may not comply with Article 9 are generally not detailed enough for me, such as for evaluating r... | human |
Art 9 | Scenario B | 4 | null | 5 | null | 1 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario B | 5 | null | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | human | |
Art 9 | Scenario B | 6 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | null | 4 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario B | 7 | null | 1 | null | human | |
Art 9 | Scenario B | 8 | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9. However, the excerpt generally could provide more information on misuse of the system, for which there is primarily no information provided, though which is a minor requirement. Ther... | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 9. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 9, such as a lack of adequate bias mitigation when there is potential bias inherent in the system or a lack of modifying the system itself to account for pot... | human |
Art 9 | Scenario B | 9 | null | 3 | null | 1 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario B | 10 | null | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | human | |
Art 9 | Scenario C | 1 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the AI system complies with Article 9. This is because the system generally complies with all requirements of Article 9. Additionally, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may not comply with Article 9 are generally reasonable to me, such as retraining the s... | null | 5 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario C | 2 | null | 4 | null | human | |
Art 9 | Scenario C | 3 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 9. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 9, such as continuous management of risk, especially towards vulnerable populations, or adequate training methods for users. However, the justifications and ... | human |
Art 9 | Scenario C | 4 | null | 5 | null | 2 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario C | 5 | null | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9. However, the excerpt could provide more detail on continuous risk-monitoring and possibily risks related to minors, which although both are addressed at length, don't actually provid... | human | |
Art 9 | Scenario C | 6 | 1 | I believe there is a very low probability the AI system complies with Article 9. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 9, such as adequate management of continuous risk. Additionally, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may not comply with Article 9 a... | null | 4 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario C | 7 | null | 5 | null | human | |
Art 9 | Scenario C | 8 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the AI system complies with Article 9. This is because the system generally complies with all requirements of Article 9. Additionally, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may not comply with Article 9 are generally reasonable to me, such as mitigating resid... | human |
Art 9 | Scenario C | 9 | null | 5 | null | 5 | human |
Art 9 | Scenario C | 10 | null | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 9. However, while present, there is a lack of detail for me managing post-market risk, which only gets a few direct sentences, but does not state much. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario A | 1 | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 10. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 10, such as adequately making assumptions about the data or adequately ensuring the data is representative of specific contexts, such as geography. Addition... | null | 3 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario A | 2 | null | 2 | null | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario A | 3 | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses Article 10. However, I would have liked slightly more detail on data assumptions, for which there is only 1 explicit sentence. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 10. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 10, such as the representativeness of the data to reality or adequately mitigating bias through corrective methods. Additionally, the justifications and mit... | human |
Art 10 | Scenario A | 4 | null | 4 | null | 2 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario A | 5 | null | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 10. However, while present, there is a slight lack of detail for me on many of the requirements of Section 2 of Article 10, seemingly because the other sections are addressed in greater... | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario A | 6 | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the AI system complies with Article 10. This is because the system complies with generally all requirements of Article 10. However, the system processing special categories of data, even if done adequately, raises the risk of non-compliance for me. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | null | 5 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario A | 7 | null | 2 | null | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario A | 8 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 10 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the AI system complies with Article 10. This is because the system generally complies with all requirements of Article 10. However, extensive mitigation was conducted for various risks to related to bias, representativeness, and context, with the system also using special catergori... | human |
Art 10 | Scenario A | 9 | null | 5 | null | 4 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario A | 10 | null | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 10. However, while present, there is a lack of detail for me on data requirements like cleaning, enrichment, and aggregation, which although minor, only only get about a sentence. There... | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario B | 1 | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 10. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 10, such as having data that is representative of reality or the minimization of data gaps. However, the justifications and mitigations for where the system... | null | 4 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario B | 2 | null | 5 | null | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario B | 3 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 10 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 10. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 10, such as if the data set is of adequate quality or adequately mitigating bias through corrective methods. Additionally, the justifications and mitigation... | human |
Art 10 | Scenario B | 4 | null | 5 | null | 2 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario B | 5 | null | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 10. However, while present, there is a slight lack of detail for me on many of the requirements of Section 2 of Article 10, seemingly because the other sections are addressed in greater... | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario B | 6 | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 10. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 10, such as requirements related to adequately annotating data or representativeness of data to reality.. Additionally, the justifications and mitigations f... | null | 4 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario B | 7 | null | 4 | null | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario B | 8 | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 10. However, while present, there is a lack of detail for me on assumptions about data, which only gets a sentence. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | 3 | I believe there is a moderate probability the AI system complies with Article 10. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 10, such as adequately ensuring data is representative or adequately accounting for contextual factors in data, such as geography and demographics. How... | human |
Art 10 | Scenario B | 9 | null | 5 | null | 2 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario B | 10 | null | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 10. However, while present, there is a lack of detail for me on data requirements like cleaning or annotations, which although minor, only get about a sentence. Therefore, I am giving i... | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario C | 1 | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses Article 10. However, the noting of issues like data gaps, even mitigated, reduces my confidence enouigh that I cannot give this a 5. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | null | 5 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario C | 2 | null | 2 | null | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario C | 3 | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt misses a few parts of Article 10. Primarily, I believe the excerpt does not adequately detail requirements related to the context where the system is being used and adequately address special catergories of data, which I think ar... | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the AI system complies with Article 10. This is because the system complies with generally all requirements of Article 10. However, the system processing special categories of data, even if done adequately, raises the risk of non-compliance for me. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | human |
Art 10 | Scenario C | 4 | null | 5 | null | 4 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario C | 5 | null | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 10 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario C | 6 | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 10. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 10, such as requirements related to yjr representativeness of data to reality or mitigating bias caused by data. Additionally, the justifications and mitiga... | null | 5 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario C | 7 | null | 2 | null | human | |
Art 10 | Scenario C | 8 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 10 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 10. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 10, such as adequately identifying known risk or adequately mitigating known risks. Additionally, the justifications and mitigations for where the system ma... | human |
Art 10 | Scenario C | 9 | null | 4 | null | 2 | human |
Art 10 | Scenario C | 10 | null | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 10 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario A | 1 | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 12, such as comprehensive logging that adequately identifies risks. However, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may not comply with Art... | null | 3 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario A | 2 | null | 5 | null | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario A | 3 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 12 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | 1 | I believe there is a very low probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 12, such as comprehensive and continuous logging relevant to identifying risks. Additionally, the justifications and mitigations for where the system m... | human |
Art 12 | Scenario A | 4 | null | 3 | null | 5 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario A | 5 | null | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 12 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario A | 6 | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 12, such as traceability relevant to identifying high riskks or input data requirements. However, the justifications and mitigations for where the system ma... | null | 3 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario A | 7 | null | 1 | null | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario A | 8 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 12 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | 1 | I believe there is a very low probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 12, such as adequately logging risks comprehensively or adequately complying with requirements related to input data. Additionally, the justifications ... | human |
Art 12 | Scenario A | 9 | null | 3 | null | 1 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario A | 10 | null | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 12 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario B | 1 | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 12, such as comprehensive logging that adequately identifies risks or continuous logging that occurs beyond only specific contexts or moments, such as high-... | null | 4 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario B | 2 | null | 1 | null | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario B | 3 | 3 | I believe there is a moderate probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses Article 12. However, the excerpt only implicitly provides detail that it complies with requirements related to input data and the identification of natural persons. Therefore, I am giving it a 3. | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 12, such as comprehensive logging that is adequately automated. However, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may not comply with Article... | human |
Art 12 | Scenario B | 4 | null | 5 | null | 1 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario B | 5 | null | 3 | I believe there is a moderate probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses Article 12. However, I would have liked more detail in general and there is seemingly little no detail on requirements related to input data and identification of natural persons. Therefore, I am giving i... | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario B | 6 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system complies with generally all requirements of Article 12. Additionally, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may not comply with Article 12 are generally reasonable to me, such as supplementing... | null | 5 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario B | 7 | null | 2 | null | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario B | 8 | 3 | I believe there is a moderate probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses Article 12. However, the excerpt does not provide any direct information on the minor requirement related to natural persons overseeing the system. Therefore, I am giving it a 3. | 1 | I believe there is a very low probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 12, such as logging adequately comprehensive of risks. Additionally, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may not comply with Articl... | human |
Art 12 | Scenario B | 9 | null | 3 | null | 4 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario B | 10 | null | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 12. However, there is little to no detail on requirements related to the identification of natural persons, which is a minor requirement. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario C | 1 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system complies with generally all requirements of Article 12. Additionally, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may not comply with Article 12 are generally reasonable to me, such as formally iden... | null | 5 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario C | 2 | null | 1 | null | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario C | 3 | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 12. However, the excerpt only implicitly provides detail that it complies with requirements related to the identification of natural persons. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system complies with generally all requirements of Article 12. Additionally, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may not comply with Article 12 are generally reasonable to me, such as prioritizing ... | human |
Art 12 | Scenario C | 4 | null | 4 | null | 2 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario C | 5 | null | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 12. However, while possibly implicitly mentioned, I would like explicit detail on requirements related to input data and the identification of natural persons. Therefore, I am giving it... | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario C | 6 | 2 | I believe there is a low probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 12, such as comprehensive logging and traceability relevant to identifying high risks. However, the justifications and mitigations for where the system may ... | null | 4 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario C | 7 | null | 5 | null | human | |
Art 12 | Scenario C | 8 | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 12 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the AI system complies with Article 12. This is because the system generally complies with all requirements of Article 12. However, there is little to no detail on requirements related to input data and identification of natural persons. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | human |
Art 12 | Scenario C | 9 | null | 3 | null | 1 | human |
Art 12 | Scenario C | 10 | null | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 12. However, there is little to no detail on requirements related to the identification of natural persons, which is a minor requirement. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | human | |
Art 14 | Scenario A | 1 | 1 | I believe there is a very low probability the AI system complies with Article 14. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 14, such as providing an adequate stop button or other interventions or adequately providing information to users through the system to manage risk or ... | null | 5 | human |
Art 14 | Scenario A | 2 | null | 1 | null | human | |
Art 14 | Scenario A | 3 | 4 | I believe there is a high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 14. However, I would like to see more detail on requirements related to bias. Therefore, I am giving it a 4. | 1 | I believe there is a very low probability the AI system complies with Article 14. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 14, such as providing a stop button and other interventions or adequately informing human operators about the system. Additionally, the justifications ... | human |
Art 14 | Scenario A | 4 | null | 3 | null | 1 | human |
Art 14 | Scenario A | 5 | null | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 14 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | human | |
Art 14 | Scenario A | 6 | 1 | I believe there is a very low probability the AI system complies with Article 14. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 14, such as providing a stop button or other interventions or notifications or information adequately supporting human oversight. Additionally, the jus... | null | 5 | human |
Art 14 | Scenario A | 7 | null | 1 | null | human | |
Art 14 | Scenario A | 8 | 3 | I believe there is a moderate probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses Article 14. However, I would like more information on mitigating bias, for which there is primarily only 1 sentence, and more information on intervention methods available to users, for which only a stop ... | 1 | I believe there is a very low probability the AI system complies with Article 14. This is because the system generally does not comply with many requirements of Article 14, such as providing to users adequate stop mechanisms and intervention mechanisms or providing to users information about the system to adequately ha... | human |
Art 14 | Scenario A | 9 | null | 3 | null | 1 | human |
Art 14 | Scenario A | 10 | null | 5 | I believe there is a very high probability the excerpt is plausible. This is because the excerpt generally addresses all aspects of Article 14 in adequate detail without leaving anything significant out. Therefore, I am giving it a 5. | human |
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 6